Posted by: colorblindcupid | June 30, 2008

Community Values: Part Three

A while back, Love Generously wrote two articles called Community Values and Community Values, Part Two. If you didn’t read them (and aren’t going to) the gist was that her husband got a new job much further from their home, but they chose not to move because they’d have to live in white bread suburbia, and they thought it was better for their Hispanic kids to live in their current mixed race community. Part Two gave a real life example of how their community affects them in that capacity (her daughter going to the ballet and getting to see a Hispanic ballerina).

We had some disagreement on my part because my personal opinion was that I’d rather live in Whitesville than lose an extra 2 hours a day with my kid’s father. I felt that time with DD’s father would trump having easy access to a rainbow of faces in daily life, arguing that you could still take your kid to the ballet or wherever the non-white people abound if that was important to you.

My opinion on that hasn’t changed – I’d personally still choose having my husband for 2 extra hours; however, I have been thinking recently how much what she said has merit in my family’s life. Thankfully, my family wasn’t put in the same situation as LG’s (having to choose where to live because of a job change), which makes my decision much easier. I don’t have to think about things like that because DD sees Indian people all the time and all the other races, too, on a daily basis. She’s the only brown kid when we go somewhere as often as she’s in the racial majority (or just the “brown colored” people majority anyway).

One of DD’s favorite haunts is our city’s Children’s Museum. Though the museum is located in a primarily mixed ethnicity area (white being the most prominent still though), on any given day the majority of kids there may be black, due to field trips and camp trips of primarily black schools, which we have a large number of in our city. On a recent trip to the museum, I was given pause to remember LG’s articles. The museum has a miniature room (sized for little kids!) that DD likes, and she and I were having a tiny tea party. A trio of black boys (about 7-8 yrs old) from a field trip peeked in the room (we were the only ones in there – it’s like our secret place) and asked if we were having a tea party. We said yes and asked if they’d like to join us. They did and DD served them all tea and cookies, which they proceeded to pretend to eat. She was so prim and proper serving them, and I couldn’t believe they’d want to have “tea” with a 4-year-old! But they all seemed to have a blast.

She’s never once asked me about another person’s skin color or obvious cultural differences (like clothing, etc.) – not when we go to an Indian event and I’m one of the only (if not only) white person there, not at the zoo where it’s a multi-culti fest complete with a large number of Amish visitors, and not even when we visit the museum and both she and I are usually in the minority. I have wondered on occasion if she’s just not attuned to it, but I don’t think that’s it.

Later that evening at dinner, she was telling Saresh how much fun she had at the museum and about how she made new friends at her tea party. Then she says, “I liked their hair. It was short and black, like yours used to be before you shaved it.” Then she babbled on about the rest of her day. I loved that the boys’ hair is what caught her fancy that day, and that they reminded her of her dad.

DD’s growing up so differently than I did (rural Whitesville) and it gives me a lot of hope for the future, especially when I see grown-ups behaving so badly. For her, people are just people and she expects them to be/look different because that’s all she sees on a daily basis – a great big bunch of people who ALL look different from each other. She likes to look through my magazines and say which of her friends the kids in the magazine look like. She never points out their eye shape or skin color or even asks any questions about them – it’s just, “this girl looks like Sophia!” (Chinese) and “this girl looks like Melissa!” (mixed race) and “this girl looks like Claire!” (white). When everybody’s “different,” basically no one is to her. It’s a non-issue, and I hope it stays one in her life. I think she will be confused as she gets older when she finds out how much of an issue some people make it. I wish I could feel what it was like to look through her eyes right now.


Responses

  1. CBC, what a beautiful post! That is really amazing, and so how it should be. You put it so well when you said, “When everybody’s ‘different,’ basically no one is to her.” I loved that line, and her hair comment, too. It’s honestly one of the sweetest things I’ve ever heard.

    I hope she’s always allowed by her peers to just see people as people, and that no one tries to get her to self-select into either being “like them” or “not like them.” I think that is where the races and ethnicities run into problems – when they begin excluding people not like them or requiring conformity to accept those not like them. It sounds like, if most kids stay from elementary school to high school in the school district/community, that may not ever happen, and that truly would mark the beginning of an amazing change in the world.

  2. I don’t know how I missed LG’s earlier posts, btw – I just read them and those were great – but I thought combined, these raised such an interesting issue about the degree to which to emphasize a child’s cultural history.

    I think this might make an interesting post (if you ever feel like writing it), because it’s such a complex issue but profoundly important issue. It’s totally understandable that no one would want their child to feel excluded from something they were supposed to be a part of – that other people who look like them are a big part of. But at the same time, I can’t help but think that the overemphasis on “shared histories” and “shared culture” stunts development in the way DD seems to be developing – as seeing people as people.

    What ever happend to LG, btw?? She didn’t want to post anymore?

    Another issue I saw with them not moving was that, while I totally understand what she’s aiming for, it’s the wealthy, white school districts that often have the best schools, and what examples the other children set will influence what Sunshine achieves – what college she goes to, what opportunities she has. I think that influence is huge and worth taking into account (especially as Sunshine gets into middle school or so).

    And maybe it will change by then, but unfortunately not all inroads into “the establishment” have been made by minorities and females. Whether it’s working on Wall St seeing very few senior women or being at law school with very few other “brown” people or whatever, there’s something to be said for just exposing people to the best of the best in an area, and letting them learn how to achieve that while being a minority.

    It’s not a simple issue, but I think there is a lot of merit on all these sides.

  3. While there is some truth to the “it’s the wealthy, white school districts that often have the best schools” that is not always the case. Especially in California where there are districts that are predominantly Asian that outshine most other districts.
    While academics are important, social development is equally important. Chris Rock’s parents sent him to an all white school, had no friends and had major issues. He wet his bed until adulthood. Academics aren’t everything.
    Love the post though. In India, race used to be an issue a long time ago. Race now plays a subservient role to religion and linguistics. The world a child inhabits is a pure and innocent place. They should live there as long as possible.

  4. Basically, LG has 3 kids and the older two are school age, meaning many activities plus a toddler in tow. She’s also a freelance writer and works from home. She approached me initially about writing for the blog, but I think it was more time consuming than she realized. When I took my last “blog break” she decided to lay off as well. She said she’d write occasionally, but I think that was wishful thinking. ;)

    I wish she could though because she and CA usually had differing philosophies, esp regarding child rearing, so it made for good balance as far as posts went. I think I fell somewhere in the middle (as usual!). Saresh always asks me, “How’s that fence feel?”

    I think a lot of her thought differed in that her children were adopted from Guatemala, and she also has an open adoption with the birth mother in Guat (for the oldest child). They have visited there a few times. I just don’t know anything about adoption psychology or thought or what’s the new word there as far as raising kids, esp from other countries. Whereas CA and I had a different situation in that our spouses were the “other half” of the race/ethnicity of our children and so we don’t have to think about/worry about exposing our kids per se to the culture they came from. I know LG went through a lot of pre-adoption courses with family services and the international adoption agency related to the kinds of stuff she wrote about, especially related to preconceived notions people might have about their kids being Hispanic or black or just a different race than the parents. I know CA usually was thinking more along the lines that you mentioned in the beginning of your comment.

  5. I have just come back from visiting my close friend in San Francisco, and I have a confession. I was really, really suprised at how many different cultures have settled in the city and surrounding areas. Mexican, Chinese, Indian, Irish, Italian….many Americans I met were a quarter this, half this and a third of that lol. But I really didn’t expect it. I guess there are going to be “white places” dotted around everywhere, but I think different cultures are beautifully mingling across the world, and I think that, even if you are living in a predominantly white area, I really don’t think it will be white forever. I know my area in England has drastically changed in the past 10 years.

    Love the blog. Made me question about what I would do.


Categories